Unlawful Dismissal in Serbia: How an Employee Gets Their Job Back and Recovers Lost Wages

A dismissal almost never comes at a moment when you are ready for it. The decision is handed to you on a Friday afternoon, you are given a few minutes to collect your things and told the decision is final. At that moment most employees are thinking about how they will pay the next loan installment, not about the possibility that the employer has just breached several provisions of the Labor Law.

Practice shows that a large number of dismissals in Serbia do not stand up in court. The reason rarely lies in the employer having no grounds for termination at all. Much more often it is a formal error: a skipped step in the procedure, reasoning that comes down to a single sentence or a decision that does not contain what the law expressly requires. In an employment dispute, the court first looks at whether the procedure was carried out correctly, and only then at whether the reason for dismissal is true.

This article explains when a dismissal is lawful, which employer mistakes most often void the decision, within what deadline you must act and what you can realistically obtain if you win. It is written from the perspective of an employee who has just received a termination decision and is trying to understand what to do, but it will also be useful to employers who want to avoid an expensive and lengthy dispute.

When a dismissal is lawful

The Labor Law does not allow an employer to terminate employment whenever it wishes. Dismissal is possible only for the reasons exhaustively listed in the law, and in a court dispute the burden of proving that such a reason exists lies entirely with the employer. This is one of the most important provisions for the employee, because it means you do not have to prove your innocence. The employer must prove your fault.

The statutory grounds for dismissal fall into three large groups, and each carries a different procedure and a different defense.

Grounds relating to work ability and performance

This group covers situations where the employee does not achieve the required results or lacks the knowledge and skills needed for their job. It is the reason employers state most easily and prove with the most difficulty. The court looks for an objective standard. If the company has no defined targets, no job description with measurable goals and no written appraisal system, the claim that someone is not achieving results remains the manager’s personal opinion and as a rule does not hold up.

Grounds relating to the employee’s conduct

This includes breach of work duties, breach of work discipline, coming to work under the influence of alcohol or psychoactive substances, unjustified absence from work and the like. The key point is that the breach the employee is charged with must be defined in advance by law, by the employer’s general rules or by the employment contract. The employer cannot invent a breach after the event and punish you for it.

For more serious breaches the law allows immediate dismissal, but even then a procedure must be followed. For minor breaches of work discipline the employer must first impose a lighter measure, for example a warning or temporary suspension, and only if the behavior is repeated can it move on to dismissal.

Grounds relating to the employer’s needs

This is so called technological, economic or organizational redundancy. Here the employer does not claim you did anything wrong, but that the job you were doing is no longer needed. This ground has the strictest formal rules, which we discuss in a separate part of the article.

The procedure the employer must follow

This is the part employees most often overlook, and in practice it decides more disputes than the substance of the reason for dismissal. The law sets out a clear sequence of steps, and skipping any of them leads to the decision being annulled, however well founded the reason may have been.

Steps the employer must complete before handing you the decision:

  • Where the dismissal is based on the employee’s conduct or performance, the employer must give the employee a written warning before issuing the termination decision.
  • The warning must describe the specific act or omission, state the provision that was breached and set out the facts and evidence on which the claim is based. A general warning without a description of the event has no effect.
  • The employee has at least eight days from delivery of the warning to respond in writing. That deadline must actually be given, it cannot be shortened, and a response cannot be demanded on the spot.
  • A copy of the warning is sent to the trade union the employee belongs to, if the employer has been informed of the membership, and the union has the right to give its opinion.
  • The termination decision must be in writing, with reasons and instructions on legal remedies, and must be delivered to the employee personally.
  • The decision must be issued within the statutory deadline, which for a breach of work duties is six months from learning of the facts, or one year from when the breach occurred.
Employment lawyer in Belgrade reviewing a termination decision
Before any step toward the employer, the decision is read: was a warning delivered, was a deadline given for a response, and does the reason in the decision match the one in the warning.

Employer mistakes that void the decision

In the disputes we handle, a relatively small number of errors keep recurring. If you recognize one of them in your decision, you have serious grounds for a lawsuit.

The errors we see most often:

  • The reasoning merely copies a statutory provision, without describing the specific event, date and consequence. A court cannot even review such a decision, so it annuls it.
  • The decision states a different reason from the one given in the warning. The employer is bound by what it charged the employee with in the warning.
  • The employee was denied the right to respond or was given a shorter deadline than the law requires.
  • The employer had already imposed a measure for the same breach and then also dismissed the employee for the same act.
  • The decision was issued after the six month deadline from learning of the breach had expired.
  • Other employees were not punished for the same omission, which raises the question of discrimination and abuse of rights.
  • The decision was not delivered personally, but left on a desk, sent by text message or dictated over the phone.
  • In a redundancy, no redundancy program was adopted, even though the number of employees affected exceeded the statutory threshold.

The deadline for a lawsuit is short and cannot be extended

This is the most important piece of information in the whole article. An employee who believes their employment was terminated unlawfully has sixty days from the day the decision was delivered to file a lawsuit with the competent court. This is a preclusive deadline. Once it has passed, the right to protection in court is irrevocably lost, however obviously unlawful the dismissal was.

The deadline runs from delivery of the decision, not from the day you stopped going to work and not from the day the final payment was made. If you refused to accept the decision and the employer recorded the refusal in the presence of two witnesses, the decision is considered delivered. Refusing to accept it therefore does not help you and only shortens the time you have to respond.

Filing a complaint with the employer, appealing to management, reporting to the labor inspectorate or talking to the trade union does not interrupt or stop this deadline. The labor inspectorate may order the enforcement of the decision to be postponed, but that does not replace a lawsuit. We have seen too many cases in which an employee waited three months for a response from the inspectorate and so lost the right to a dispute they would certainly have won.

What the court can award

If the court finds the dismissal unlawful, it annuls the decision and rules on the consequences. As a rule, the employee can claim several things at once, and the choice depends on whether they want to return to the same employer.

Reinstatement

The court orders the employer to return the employee to the job they were doing or to a job that matches their qualifications. This is the basic claim and is made in most lawsuits, even when the employee does not actually plan to return, because it strengthens the negotiating position for a settlement.

Compensation for lost wages

The employer must pay compensation equal to the wages lost from the end of employment until reinstatement, reduced by any amounts the employee earned from work in the meantime. In addition, the related taxes and contributions are paid, which fills the gap in the employee’s service record and pension base. This part is often overlooked, but financially it is very significant.

Monetary compensation instead of reinstatement

If the employee does not want to return, or if the court finds that continued employment with that employer is not possible because the relationship has broken down, compensation of up to eighteen monthly salaries is awarded instead of reinstatement. The amount depends on length of service, age, the number of dependent family members and the circumstances of the dismissal.

Compensation for non-material damage

When the dismissal was accompanied by harassment, public humiliation or discrimination, it is also possible to claim compensation for non-material damage for injury to honor and reputation. This claim requires separate evidence and is usually brought together with the claims in the employment dispute.

Employment dispute in a Belgrade court over unlawful dismissal
If the court finds the dismissal unlawful, it annuls the decision and rules on reinstatement, lost wages and contributions for the entire period.

Redundancy, and when even that is unlawful

The end of the need for an employee’s work because of technological, economic or organizational changes is a legitimate reason, but it comes with a series of obligations that employers often fail to meet.

The first obligation is to pay severance. Severance is calculated as at least one third of the employee’s salary for each full year of employment with the employer. The termination decision cannot be issued before the severance has been paid. If you have been handed the decision but the severance has not arrived, the decision is unlawful for that reason alone.

The second obligation arises when the dismissal affects a larger number of employees within a thirty day period. The employer must then adopt a redundancy program, inform the trade union and the national employment service, and consider their opinions. The program must contain criteria for identifying redundant employees, and those criteria must not be discriminatory.

The third obligation concerns the substance itself. If your position has been abolished and a month later the employer advertises the same job under a different title, it is clear that the need for the work has not ended. This is one of the most common ways of proving that the redundancy was merely a cover for dismissal on impermissible grounds.

Special protection for certain categories of employees

The law provides absolute or enhanced protection for certain groups of employees, for whom dismissal is prohibited or possible only under stricter conditions.

The protection applies in the following situations:

  • An employer may not terminate the employment contract of a woman during pregnancy, or of an employee on maternity leave, childcare leave or leave for special care of a child. The protection continues for thirty days after the leave ends.
  • An employer may not terminate an employment contract because of temporary incapacity for work due to illness, an accident at work or an occupational disease, or because the employee turned to a trade union or a competent authority.
  • An employee representative enjoys protection while holding the role and for one year after it ends, provided they act in accordance with the law and the collective agreement.
  • Dismissal because of trade union membership, sex, age, health, disability, marital status, family obligations, religion or political beliefs is discrimination and carries special liability for the employer.

Mutual termination and resignation under pressure

It increasingly happens that the employer does not issue a termination decision at all, but proposes to the employee that the employment end by mutual agreement. The argument is always the same: it is easier for both sides, and you will find a new job faster because your record will not show that you were dismissed.

What is not said is that by ending your employment by mutual agreement you lose the right to unemployment benefit from the National Employment Service, lose the right to severance pay and practically waive the right to protection in court. A signed agreement is very difficult to overturn.

An agreement can be annulled only if it is proven that consent was given under threat or by mistake, which is a demanding procedure in terms of evidence. So the rule is simple. Never sign an agreement to end your employment on the spot. Ask for a copy to read at home, say you will respond the next day and get advice in the meantime. An employer who does not allow you to do so reveals that something is wrong.

The same applies to resignation. If it is suggested that you resign yourself to avoid unpleasantness, be aware that you are taking all the negative consequences on yourself and relieving the employer of every obligation.

What to do in the first seven days

The first few days decide how strong your case will be. During this period the evidence is still available and the deadlines have not expired.

Steps to take immediately:

  • Keep the termination decision, the warning, the employment contract with all its annexes, the job description and all payslips for the last year.
  • Make copies of correspondence that mentions the reason for dismissal, including messages from your work e-mail if you still have access. Access to accounts is usually cut off immediately, so do this on the first day.
  • Write down the names and contact details of colleagues who witnessed the disputed events. Witnesses are often decisive in employment disputes.
  • Register with the National Employment Service within the statutory deadline, so that you can receive unemployment benefit if you meet the conditions.
  • Check whether you have been paid for unused annual leave and whether all contributions have been paid. Missing service years go into the same claim as the lawsuit.
  • Book a consultation with an employment lawyer before you respond to the employer in writing.
An employee bringing employment documents to a consultation with a lawyer
The decision, the warning, the employment contract with its annexes and the payslips for the last year are the documents to bring to the first meeting.

How long a dispute takes and what it costs

Employment disputes are urgent proceedings, which in practice means the court schedules hearings at shorter intervals than in other civil cases. Even so, the realistic duration of first instance proceedings in Belgrade is usually between one and two years, and if the case is sent back for retrial it can take longer.

The employee is exempt from paying the court fee for the lawsuit in an employment dispute, which significantly reduces the cost of starting. What remains are the costs of representation, calculated according to the tariff of the Bar Association of Serbia. If you win, the employer must reimburse your legal costs.

In a significant number of cases a judgment is never reached, because employers agree to a settlement once they realize the decision will not stand. A settlement negotiated through a lawyer usually brings a faster and more certain outcome than a judgment, and the employee gets the money months earlier. The decision whether to accept an offer or continue the dispute is made on the basis of an assessment of the evidence, not an impression.

Frequently Asked Questions

How long do I have to file a lawsuit for unlawful dismissal?

The deadline is sixty days from the day the termination decision was delivered. It is a preclusive deadline, which means that once it passes the right to sue is lost permanently and cannot be restored. A report to the labor inspectorate, a complaint to the employer or contacting the trade union does not stop this deadline.

Can I win the case if I signed for receipt of the decision?

Yes. Your signature on the decision only means that you received it on that day, not that you agree with its content. Receiving the decision does not in any way reduce your right to seek its annulment. If you want extra certainty, add a note next to your signature that you accept the decision while expressly disagreeing with the reasons.

My employer did not give me a written warning before the dismissal. Is that enough for annulment?

Where the dismissal is based on the employee’s conduct or performance, the absence of a written warning is a material breach of procedure and as a rule leads to the decision being annulled without the court examining whether the reason was well founded. A warning is not required for dismissal because the employee’s work is no longer needed.

What exactly can I get if I win?

The court annuls the decision and reinstates you, and the employer must pay your lost wages with taxes and contributions for the whole period. If you do not want to return, you can instead claim monetary compensation of up to eighteen monthly salaries. You are also awarded your legal costs and, in some cases, compensation for non-material damage.

Can my employer dismiss me while I am on sick leave?

Not because of the temporary incapacity for work itself. Dismissal for another lawful reason during sick leave is possible, but the court will examine such a decision with particular care, because the timing coinciding with sick leave is taken as a circumstance indicating a possible abuse of rights.

I signed a mutual termination agreement under pressure. Can I do anything?

You can seek annulment of the agreement because of a defect of consent, but you must prove a threat or a mistake. This is much harder than an ordinary employment dispute and requires concrete evidence, such as messages, recordings or witnesses to the conversation. That is why it is always better not to sign on the spot than to challenge a signed agreement later.

Did my severance have to be paid before I received the redundancy decision?

Yes. The employer must pay the severance before issuing a decision terminating employment on that ground. A decision issued without the severance having been paid first is unlawful, regardless of whether the need for your work has actually ended.

How much does an employment dispute cost and do I pay a court fee?

In an employment dispute the employee is exempt from the court fee for the lawsuit. What remains are the costs of legal representation, calculated according to the tariff of the Bar Association of Serbia, with the possibility of agreeing on how they are paid. If you win, the employer bears the costs of the proceedings.

Can I claim compensation if I have found a new job in the meantime?

You can. The right to have the decision annulled remains, and compensation for lost wages is reduced by the amounts you earned from work in the meantime. If your new salary is lower than before, the difference can still be claimed. In that situation the claim for reinstatement is usually replaced by a claim for monetary compensation.

Related on this site

Read also

The first thing you should do is have someone who handles these cases read your decision. In a single meeting we can establish whether the procedure was carried out correctly, how much time you have left and what your claim is realistically worth. We represent employees and employers in employment disputes before the courts in Belgrade, and consultations are also available online or by phone, in English.

Employment Law →
← All articles
WhatsApp
+381 64 4100040