LLC (DOO) or Sole Proprietor in Serbia: How to Choose the Legal Form That Protects You

Ana is a freelancer who writes software for two clients in Germany. For years she has been invoicing through her personal account, and now she wants to put the business on a proper legal footing. She asks one colleague and gets the answer: register as a sole proprietor, it is fast and cheap. She asks another: set up a DOO, it looks more serious to foreign clients.

Nikola and Vuk are opening a bakery. They are leasing premises, taking a loan for equipment and hiring four people. The same colleague gave them the same advice: start as sole proprietors and see later.

The first piece of advice is probably good for Ana. For Nikola and Vuk it is potentially expensive in a way that is measured not in dinars but in family assets. That is the core of the problem when the legal form is chosen by how it sounds, rather than by what it actually means in terms of liability, taxes and the ability to exit the business.

According to the statistics of the Serbian Business Registers Agency (APR), more than 350,000 sole proprietors and around 140,000 companies are registered in Serbia. Both forms are widespread, but for very different reasons and with very different consequences. In this article we break down what really distinguishes them: their legal nature, the founders’ liability, taxation, costs and the situations in which one form is clearly better than the other.

The basic difference: what a sole proprietor and a DOO are

A sole proprietor (preduzetnik) is not a company, even though it is often called one in everyday speech. The Companies Act defines a sole proprietor as an individual with legal capacity who carries on an activity in order to earn income and who is registered in accordance with the law on registration. A sole proprietor has no share capital, no founding act, no shareholders’ meeting and no management bodies. Legally, the sole proprietor and their business are one and the same. When a sole proprietor signs a contract, it is the individual who signs it, using a business name in legal transactions.

A company, by contrast, is a legal entity that carries on an activity in order to make a profit and acquires legal personality by registration in the Register of Business Entities. The member and the company are two separate legal entities. The practical consequence is significant: a member can sell their share, transfer the company to someone else, admit a new member or withdraw from management, and the company continues to exist. A sole proprietor cannot do this, because the business cannot be separated from the person.

In practice we most often see founders choose the form based on what they heard from acquaintances or what sounded more serious, rather than on an analysis of the tax and property consequences. That is a mistake that in some cases is measured in thousands of euros a year, and in others in the entire value of an apartment.

Liability: all your personal assets or only your contribution

A sole proprietor is liable with all of their assets

An unpleasant truth clients rarely hear before registering: a sole proprietor who ends up owing money to a supplier, a bank or the Tax Administration can lose the apartment they live in. The liability is unlimited, extends to assets acquired outside the business, and does not end when the sole proprietor is removed from the register for obligations incurred while the business was active.

An analogy that helps clients understand it: a sole proprietor is like a driver who drives their own car without third party liability insurance. If there is damage, they pay out of their own pocket. A DOO member is like the driver of a company car with full cover, because their personal financial risk is limited in advance.

For low risk freelance professions, such as consultants, developers, translators or designers who do not take loans or hold stock, this unlimited liability is abstract. For activities involving leases, loans, employees, goods on deferred payment or contractual penalties toward foreign clients, it becomes a very concrete problem. Nikola and Vuk from our example have a loan, a lease and four employees. For them, the risk is measured not by probability but by consequence.

A DOO member risks their contribution

A member of a limited liability company is not liable for the company’s obligations with their own assets. Their maximum financial risk is the value of the contribution they made to the company. The statutory minimum share capital is 100 dinars, a symbolic amount, but keep in mind that for certain regulated activities special laws prescribe significantly higher capital requirements.

It is important here to separate two things that are often confused in practice. Limited liability protects the member, but it does not protect the director. The director is liable to the company for damage caused by breaching the duties of care and loyalty and, in certain situations, also to creditors and under the tax procedure rules. When one person is both member and director, which is the most common situation in Serbian single member companies, the protection they feel as owners does not cover what they do as directors.

Piercing the corporate veil

Limited liability is not absolute. Article 18 of the Companies Act provides for piercing the corporate veil, a situation in which a creditor breaks through the company’s shield and collects directly from the member. This happens when a member abuses the company for unlawful or fraudulent purposes, disposes of the company’s assets as their own, mixes business and personal assets or takes money out of the company just before insolvency, knowing that the company will not be able to meet its obligations.

The practical conclusion we give clients is simple: limited liability is preserved by running the business properly. Separate accounts, proper documentation of every transfer between the member and the company, contracts instead of verbal arrangements and real fees for real work. A company used as a personal wallet stops being a shield at the very moment it is needed.

Liability after compulsory liquidation

The second exception is less well known and in practice the source of the nastiest surprises. When the Business Registers Agency starts and carries out compulsory liquidation, for example because the company has not filed its financial statements for two years, and the company is deleted from the register, the controlling member of the limited liability company becomes jointly and severally liable without limit for the obligations of the deleted company. Creditors’ claims against the members become time barred three years after the company is deleted from the register.

A controlling member is a person who, alone or together with related persons, holds a majority stake in the capital. The courts have confirmed this provision in a number of cases, including proceedings in which interrupted enforcement was continued against the sole member of a deleted company.

Choosing a legal form, sole proprietor or company, at a law office in Belgrade
The form is chosen before registration. Afterwards every correction costs more, and for a sole proprietor, obligations incurred until deregistration remain with the individual.

Taxation of a sole proprietor

The first regime is flat rate taxation. The Tax Administration determines a deemed income by decision, based on the activity code, the municipality and other prescribed criteria, and tax and contributions are calculated on that income as a fixed monthly amount. A flat rate taxpayer does not keep double entry books and does not have to prove expenses, which keeps administration to a minimum. There are two limitations: annual turnover in a calendar year must not exceed RSD 6,000,000, and the flat rate is not available by law for certain activities. The list of excluded activities has changed with amendments to the law, so it should always be checked for the specific code before registration.

The second regime is taxation of actual income, with business books kept. The tax base is the difference between business income and tax deductible expenses, and the tax rate on income from self-employment is 10 percent, plus mandatory social security contributions.

The third option, which many sole proprietors do not consider seriously enough, is opting to pay themselves a personal salary. In that case the sole proprietor pays themselves a salary that is treated as a business expense, which directly affects the tax base, while tax and contributions are calculated on the salary itself. The choice to take a personal salary must be notified to the Tax Administration within the statutory deadline before the start of the year to which it applies, which means a missed deadline costs a whole year.

Which regime is more favorable depends on the level and stability of income, the structure of expenses, the number of employees and plans for the next two to three years. It is a calculation done with real numbers, not a choice made by rule of thumb.

Taxation of a DOO: corporate income tax and dividend tax

The company pays corporate income tax at a rate of 15 percent on taxable profit, which is determined as the difference between income and tax deductible expenses under the Corporate Income Tax Law. This is the part founders usually know.

The part they rarely hear before registering comes later. When the company decides to distribute profit to a member as a dividend, that income is taxed again, this time as an individual’s capital income, at a rate of 15 percent. In tax terminology this is economic double taxation.

There are alternatives, and each has its price. The profit can be reinvested in the company, which defers the second round of tax while the money stays in the business. A member who works in the company can receive a salary as director or employee, which is a business expense of the company but carries tax and contributions on the salary. For foreign members, double taxation treaties also apply, which often reduce the withholding tax rate on dividends. Which combination is best depends on how much money the owner really needs from the business, and when.

The VAT threshold is the same for both forms

This question is constantly confused with the question of legal form, so it is worth setting apart. The obligation to register for VAT arises when total turnover exceeds RSD 8,000,000, not in a calendar year but in any 12 consecutive months. The legal form has no bearing on this. A sole proprietor and a company enter the VAT system at the same threshold, and both can register voluntarily before reaching it.

Costs of formation and running

Formation

Registration of a sole proprietor and formation of a company are now filed electronically, with a qualified electronic certificate and payment of the fee by card. For a company, the fee is accompanied by drafting the founding act, certifying signatures and, when the founder is a foreign legal entity, assembling the registration documents from the home country with an apostille and a certified translation. That part is the most common cause of delay in setting up companies with foreign capital, so preparing the documents is planned in parallel with the other steps, not after them.

The cost of starting a business, item by item.
CostSole proprietorDOO
APR feeRSD 2,500RSD 8,000
Minimum share capitalNoneRSD 100
Founding actNot requiredRequired, with certified signatures
Certified documentsIdentification document onlyDepends on the founders and structure: register extracts, legalization or apostille, translation into Serbian by a court interpreter

Running the business

Accounting services for a sole proprietor range roughly from EUR 50 to 150 a month, depending on the tax regime and volume of business. For a company you should realistically expect EUR 100 to 300 a month, because double entry bookkeeping is required, along with preparing and filing the annual financial statements with the APR and the corporate income tax return, as well as broader obligations relating to VAT and electronic invoicing.

A difference of EUR 600 to 1,800 a year is not in itself a reason to decide, but in the first years of business, when income is low, it adds up and becomes noticeable.

Closing down

Deregistering a sole proprietor is simple and relatively cheap. Liquidating a company is a separate procedure involving a liquidation decision, the appointment of a liquidator, publication of a notice and a deadline for creditors to file claims, liquidation reports and final deletion. The procedure realistically takes several months. In both cases, tax certificates confirming that there are no outstanding obligations to the Tax Administration and the local tax administration are obtained as a condition for deletion.

Transferring the business, investors and exit strategy

This is a difference that is invisible at the start and decisive at the end. A share in a company is a property right that can be sold, pledged, contributed to another company or inherited, through a share transfer agreement and registration of the change. A sole proprietorship cannot be sold as such, because it is tied to the person of the sole proprietor. The equipment can be sold, and a contract can be transferred with the other party’s consent, but the business itself does not pass to the buyer as a legal whole.

For the same reason, a company is the standard form when investors or co-founders join the business. The structure of shares, voting rights, decision making and exit mechanisms are set out in the founding act and the shareholders’ agreement. A sole proprietor cannot have a co-founder, because by definition there is no entity in which a share could be divided. Two partners running a business as a single sole proprietorship do not in reality have a partnership, but one business owner and one verbal agreement that is difficult to prove in court.

Converting a sole proprietorship into a DOO

Conversion is possible and is governed by Article 92 of the Companies Act. The sole proprietor adopts a decision to continue the business in the form of a company, and the sole proprietor is deleted from the register at the same time as the formation of the company is registered. The new company takes over the rights and obligations of the sole proprietor arising from the business.

What is most often left unsaid in this context is paragraph 3 of the same article. Even after ceasing to be a sole proprietor, the individual remains liable with all of their assets for all obligations arising from the business up to the moment of deletion from the register. Converting to a company therefore protects against future risks, but does not erase the past. That is why there is no version of this operation in which a problem is created first and then left behind in the old form.

The conversion also has tax and accounting consequences, including an inventory of assets and liabilities and the preparation of extraordinary financial statements, so it is planned with an accountant and a lawyer at the same time.

Summary of the differences

All of the above, reduced to a single overview of the parameters that most often decide the choice of form in practice.

Fees, rates and thresholds apply to the period when the article was published and change when the regulations change.
ParameterSole proprietorDOO
Legal natureIndividualLegal entity
Liability for obligationsUnlimited, all personal assetsLimited to the member’s contribution
Piercing the corporate veilNot applicablePossible in case of abuse (Article 18 of the Companies Act)
Minimum capitalNoneRSD 100
APR feeRSD 2,500RSD 8,000
Taxation of incomeFlat rate, books or personal salary15 percent corporate income tax
Dividend taxNot applicable15 percent on distribution to the member
Economic double taxationNoYes, effectively around 27.75 percent
VAT thresholdRSD 8,000,000 in 12 monthsRSD 8,000,000 in 12 months
Monthly accountingAround EUR 50 to 150Around EUR 100 to 300
Administrative obligationsFewerMore, including annual statements to the APR
Multiple foundersNot possiblePossible
Transfer of ownershipBusiness cannot be transferredShares can be transferred
Suitability for investorsLimitedStandard
Closing downDeregistration, simpleLiquidation, more complex procedure

How to make the decision

Ana from the opening example works for two regular clients, has no employees, no lease and no loans. The risk of creditor claims is minimal, so for her a sole proprietorship is a workable and cheaper choice. When she starts building a team and taking on contractual obligations toward larger clients, the conversation about a DOO starts to make sense. Nikola and Vuk are a different story: two partners, a loan, a lease and employees. For them, a sole proprietorship is not the cheaper option but the uninsured one.

Five questions we go through with the client, in this order:

  • Do you have or plan to have co-founders and partners? If so, the only suitable form is a company, because a sole proprietor cannot have a co-founder.
  • Is there a material risk of claims from creditors? Loans, leases, stock, employees, quality guarantees, contractual penalties toward clients. If so, a DOO protects your personal assets and should be seriously considered regardless of the cost.
  • Are you planning to bring in investors or sell the business? If so, a company with a clear share structure is practically a requirement, because an investor buys a share, not equipment.
  • What is the level and stability of your income? Income below the flat rate limit, one or two stable clients and low expenses usually favor a sole proprietorship. High or variable income, large deductible expenses or a plan to keep profits in the business change the calculation.
  • How much does administrative simplicity matter to you? This is a legitimate criterion, but the least important one. No saving on bookkeeping is worth a risk you cannot afford to bear.

Conclusion

The answer to the question of whether to set up a DOO or register as a sole proprietor does not depend on which form sounds more serious, but on three things: how much risk your business really carries, how you want to take money out of the business and whether you plan to hand the business over to someone else one day.

For most freelancers with low risk and modest income, a sole proprietorship is a rational choice. For everyone else, and especially where there are partners, loan obligations, employees or plans for investors, the form is chosen before registration, because afterwards every correction costs more.

Frequently Asked Questions

Can a sole proprietor become a DOO without closing the business?

Yes. Article 92 of the Companies Act provides for continuing the business in the form of a company, with the sole proprietor deleted and the company registered at the same time. For obligations incurred up to the deletion of the sole proprietor, the individual remains liable with all of their assets.

How much tax does a sole proprietor pay in Serbia?

It depends on the regime. There is flat rate taxation, taxation of actual income with books kept, and the option of a personal salary. Which is best depends on the level of income, the structure of expenses and the activity, so it is a matter of a specific calculation.

Can a DOO member also be the director?

Yes, and in single member companies this is the most common situation. A director who works in Serbia must be registered for mandatory social insurance, either on the basis of employment or outside employment. It is important to understand that the member’s limited liability does not cover the director’s liability for breach of duties toward the company.

How much does it cost per month to run a sole proprietorship?

Roughly EUR 50 to 150 for accounting, depending on the volume of business. On top of that come tax and contributions, the amount of which depends on the chosen regime. For a company, realistically allow EUR 100 to 300 a month for accounting, with a greater volume of administrative obligations.

Can a foreigner register as a sole proprietor in Serbia?

Yes. Serbian and foreign nationals are treated equally as regards investment. In practice, residence and work permit questions are separate from registration, so the two steps are planned together.

What is piercing the corporate veil and when does it apply?

It is the situation under Article 18 of the Companies Act in which a creditor collects a claim directly from a member of the company rather than from the company. It applies when the company is abused for unlawful or fraudulent purposes, when its assets are disposed of as one’s own and when business and personal assets are mixed.

Does a DOO have to register for VAT straight away?

No. The obligation arises when turnover exceeds RSD 8,000,000 in the previous 12 months, the same as for a sole proprietor. Voluntary registration is possible earlier, and it is sometimes commercially justified because of the right to deduct input tax.

Related on this site

Read also

If you are preparing to register a business or thinking of switching from one form to another, we can go through your actual numbers, the risk assessment and the tax consequences before you file the application. Consultations are also available online or by phone, in English.

Corporate Law →
← All articles
WhatsApp
+381 64 4100040